Goofy Things in the Pool of Radiance and the Gold Box Series

Pool of Radiance was the first time a computer game officially tried to adapt the AD&D rules into a video-game playable form.  It is a great game and hugely influential on later games.  In fact, I would say it is the Baldur's Gate of the 1980s.  It uses the first edition of the Advanced Dungeons and Dragons rules and adheres to them pretty strictly.  However, for a player brought up on more modern RPGs, Pool has some odd features hearkening back to a time when AD&D was more suited for the tabletop than the desktop.  Let me talk about some of the AD&D features in this game and the series of games it spawned :

Currency conversion.

Trying to keep track of your wealth is a real doozy when you have five different types of coins.  It makes you feel like you have traveled back in time to the United Kingdom pre-decimalization (240 pennies = 20 shillings = 1 pound, let's not get started on farthings, groats, crowns, marks and guineas).  AD&D is slightly less cumbersome, with 200 copper pieces = 20 silver pieces = 2 electrum pieces = 1 gold pieces = 1/5 platinum pieces.  Considering that 1,000 copper pieces = 5 gold pieces, you will want to find a way to exchange currency quickly.  Fortunately you can do so in the shops.  Pool all of your various currencies together on one character and buy something cheap like 10 arrows.  You should see only Platinum and maybe some Gold for change in your inventory thereafter.

Encumbrance in coins

Instead of an intuitive system like pounds, AD&D 1st edition uses coins to note encumbrance.  The idea is that 10 gold pieces (or any type of money piece) = 1 pound.  The amount of encumbrance will slow down your character in combat.  Without any strength modifier, less than or equal to 350gp = 12 squares, 700gp = 9 squares, 1050 gp = 6 squares and anything over 1050 gp and you are down to 3 squares of movement a round.  Consider that a suit of plate mail weighs 450gp and the game treats copper pieces like gold pieces for weight and you are starting to look at some hard choices.

Strength limits for female characters

Do not play a female fighter/ranger/paladin in a Gold Box game.  Even though the sex limit would soon become unfashionable in 2nd AD&D and just about every RPG thereafter, they kept it for the whole of the Gold Box series.   There is no balancing rule benefit to playing a female character in AD&D 1st Edition.

Alignment

All nine alignments of AD&D are here, but the selection is almost useless.  Only if a magical weapon is limited to a certain alignment or one of the two axes (lawful-neutral-chaos and good-neutral-evil) does it really have an effect on the game.

Money Sinks

These games will throw a lot of coin at you, but it has ways of reclaiming quite a bit of it.  Training costs 1,000gp every time you wish to level up and is required to achieve the benefits of a new level.  Note that you cannot acquire more than the experience to put you over a second level until you train up.

Identifying items costs 200gp and you pretty much have to figure out which items are magical based on clues like unusual items in a monster hoard or a large selling price.  Of course you can always expect items like Rings and Bracers to be magical.  Healing gets expensive at the temples and silver items are also not cheap.  However, the taverns offer a simple game of chance to help you out in a short money situation and you have an equal chance of doubling your money as you have to lose it.  Save and reload as necessary, the game will not punish you for it as in Baldur's Gate.

Class and level limits

In Pool, fighters can advance to level 8, clerics and magic users to level 6 and thieves to level 9.  (Why didn't they just name fighters, magic-users and clerics as warriors, wizards and priests.  "Magic-user" just rolls off the tongue, doesn't it?  "Cleric" is just a fancy title for a "priest" and "warrior" is far more evocative than the bland, generic term "fighter".)   In Pool, the only demihuman level limit you will hit is the half-elf cleric, who is limited to level 5.

Multi-classing may be a good option for a run through Pool, but your characters will start to feel underpowered if you transfer them to Curse of the Azure Bonds.  However, unless you have the patience of a saint, you should try to level up as quickly as possible to get your THAC0 down.  You will miss a lot early in the game, and having a high strength or dexterity combined with a low THAC0 score helps, so you need to level up.

In Curse you will hit the level limits for almost every class/demihuman combination, but high strength or intelligence will allow you to increase the level limits you can obtain as fighter, ranger or magic-user.  If you import characters to Secret of the Silver Blades, the level limit will seriously start to crimp your style and Pools of Darkness will be a very dark experience indeed.

It seems silly now that no other demihuman other than a half-elf can be a ranger or a cleric, none of them can be a paladin and only elves and half-elves can be a magic-user.  Well, in AD&D 1st Edition, the Player's Handbook acknowledges some additional priestly combinations, but not for player characters. Because the Gold Box series did not implement specialist mages, there are no such things as Gnome Illusionists here.

While Elves and Halflings get a +1 to Dexterity and Dwarves get a +1 to Constitution, it does not seem to have any real benefit unless you do not adjust your scores.  Nor does raising an ability score to 19 or higher in the Pool series (except for health regeneration, see below).

Four basic character classes

In Pool, you can be a Fighter, Magic-User, Cleric or Thief.  Curse, added Rangers and Paladins to the available character classes.  It did not add Druids, Assassins, Monks or Bards.  Nor did it include the additional classes like the Cavalier, Barbarian or the Thief-Acrobat found in Unearthed Arcana.  Nor are Half-Orcs a selectable race and they did not add the subrace choices in the Player's Handbook (halflings) or Unearthed Arcana.  In this sense, the game is closer to the 2nd Edition of the Rules, which did not include most of these options within its basic rules.  Multi-classing is here from the beginning, Curse added Dual-Classing.

Half-elves have the most multi-classing choices, they can be cleric/fighters, cleric/fighter/magic-users, cleric/magic-users, fighter/magic-users, fighter/thieves, fighter/thief/magic-users and magic-user/thieves.  Elves get all those combinations except the cleric combinations, but dwarves, gnomes and halflings only get the fighter/thief option.

Thieves have a wide array of abilities in AD&D, but the the game engine limits them to picking locks, disarming traps, climbing walls backstabbing.  Mages have four spells in the spell book when they begin the game, one of which is the all-powerful sleep spell and acquire one new spell per level.

One particularly annoying feature is the THAC0 improvement.  Simply put, no character is guaranteed to see a THAC0 improvement upon gaining a level or two or three or even four.  Fighters get an improvement every two levels, clerics every three levels, thieves every four levels and magic-users every five levels.  2nd Edition AD&D had a much better progression rate for most classes, especially fighters who get a one point improvement every level.

Manual inadequacies

Pool comes with a Rule Book, an Adventurer's Journal, a Quick Start Guide and a Codewheel.  The documentation of the actual AD&D 1st Edition rules is rather lacking in Pool's documentation.  The Rule Book contains character race limit and maximum class level by race table.  The Adventurer's Journal contains the money conversion formulas, the spell list, the armor list, the experience tables, the undead turning level requirements, weapons and armor permitted by class and the weapons list.

If you wanted attack and saving throw tables, hit die tables, thief ability and turn undead tables, starting money tables or weapon weights, you had to look to the Player's Handbook and Dungeon Master's Guide.

Curse's Rule Book contains Pool's tables, updated as need be for higher levels.  It also expands the maximum class level by race table to give higher level limits for high prime requisite scores.  If you want to know the bonus spells clerics get for high wisdom, the table is here, but that is the only major addition. Curse's experience tables now include the useless level titles.

Secret's Adventurer's Journal gives racial ability score modifiers, the ability adjustments for strength, dexterity and constitution (finally!), fighter/paladin/ranger number of attacks per round, and a spell parameters list. Pools' Adventurer's Journal adds no tables.

Variations from the official rules

In Pool, clerics cannot use slings and thieves cannot use short bows.  This is correct according to AD&D 1st Edition rules.  Curse allows thieves to use short bows and clerics to use staff slings.  Pools allows thieves to wear "elfin" chain mail.  This is allowed by Unearthed Arcana.

Pool uses the rules for zero hit points as given in the Dungeon Master's Guide, (death is not instantaneous at 0 HP but you can go to -10HP before true death) but does not have a recovery time.

Weapons and armor that come and go

Armor types available in Pool are Leather, Padded, Studded, Ring, Scale, Chain, Splint, Banded and Plate. In Secret, they simplified the armor by removing Padded, Studded and Splint.  Pools added them back and put in Elfin Chain Mail as well.

Weapons in Pool number 46.  Curse has the same number, but Secret reduces it to 25.  Pools ups the figure to 29.  It has been commented that Gary Gygax had quite the fascination with medieval polearms and included every one he could find in AD&D 1st Edition.  For the first games, if it was in the Player's Handbook, you would almost certainly find it in Pool.  However, if you are looking for a +2 Glaive or Cursed Voulge-Guisarme of Berserking, you are not going to find one in either Pool or Curse.

Weird Items

In addition to the never-ending variety of polearms, which appear to be completely absent as magical weapons, the other shops sell items that have little to no value in the game.  You do not need a holy symbol to Turn Undead.  Silver armor serves no obvious point, and silver weapons appear to have very limited capabilities (Wights are the only monsters you should face regularly that could require silver, but you should have magical items by that time.)   The jewelry serves no point except as a way to convert heavy coin to a light item you can later sell if you need it.  As there is no bank in this game, you will not be able to keep as much coin as you find.  You will also find items in treasure hoards that look like they serve some purpose, but usually do not.

At one point during the game, you will find a Manual of Bodily Health.  If you use it on a dwarf character with 19 Constitution, his number will not be raised, but he will gain a regeneration ability to restore his health.  This makes healing a lot faster for this character, by the time you finish resting to regain your spells, he will likely be fully healed.  Note that if your characters die and have to be resurrected through a raise dead spell, you will lose 1 point of Constitution.

Peculiarities of the IBM PC version

In Pool and Curse, all interaction is done by the keyboard IBM PC version.  In Pool, you usually use the Home and End keys to select your characters or your items, but sometimes you can use the arrow keys. The Page Up and Page Down keys can usually be used to cycle through a multi-screen menu like the one presented at the weapons/armor shops.  It can be a bit confusing, but using the numeric keypad may be a more intuitive option.  Using the numeric keypad is utterly necessary to move in combat, the cardinal four directions are insufficient for the isometric views of the combat screens.  Later games rely more on the arrow keys to select menu items.

While the joystick was an option of the Commodore 64 and Apple II versions and mouse support was in Pool's Macintosh and Commodore Amiga versions, those control options would only start to be included as of IBM PC's Secret.  Oddly enough, the Demo option found in the Commodore 64 and Apple II versions and in the PC version of every game following is missing for IBM PC Pool.

Some of the IBM PC versions of Pool do support Tandy music on their title screens just like every other version of the game except the Apple II version.  Unfortunately their music driver was not very good, leading to an odd tone played early in the main track.  Also, the music will never finish on the title screen for Pool regardless of how slow your Tandy is.  Weirdly, the music also plays when you start a battle in Pool.  It does not play music at this point in the Commodore 64 original.

Eventually they got rid of the music, at least as of version 1.2 and 1.3 (which are indicated on the credits screen, earlier versions do not indicate the version number there).  The version numbering of Pool is not generally well known due to the lack of version number display.  However, there are versions with a START.EXE of 10-26-88 and 12-12-88 according to an old crack .nfo file.  I would suggest that these are v1.0 and v1.1, respectively.  My copy has a START.EXE of 12-12-88 and does not display a version number but does play music.

Curse is similar except there was also music for the PC Speaker.  It always displays a version number and 1.0-1.3 exist.  Music was removed as of 1.3 and similar to Pool you could never hear the full theme.

If you want the versions with the music, look for the original retail box versions.  Avoid slash releases or any compilation release, especially the ones that come on CD-ROM.  I would concentrate on 5.25" double density disks if you really want to maximize your chances.

Between the two 16 color graphic drivers, the Tandy driver is far more speedy to load than the EGA driver. Interestingly, the background color in the combat screens is black for the Tandy but light gray for EGA. Curse's Tandy driver would also use light gray.

To avoid a "PUT SAVE DISK IN C:"or "INSERT DISK 3" error, make sure your directories are correct in your POOL.CFG file.  Later games let you delete their .CFG file and let you re-enter the information (graphics and sound type, game save directory and prior game directory typically), but with Pool you must manually edit your file.  Early versions of Pool do not want to be run in a sub-subdirectory, they demand being in a directory at the root of the drive.

There is a lot of plain text in the START.EXE file, including all the copy protection words.  Even though Pool's Translation Wheel gives 108 possible combinations (36 x 3), there are only 13 copy protection words While each word can be selected by three combinations of Espruar and Dethek runes, only one combination is ever used, and here is how the word and lines match up:

BEWARE - - - - -
COPPER - - - - -
FRIEND - - - - -
SAVIOR - - - - -
WYVERN - - - - -
DRAGON -..-..-..
JUNGLE -..-..-..
ZOMBIE -..-..-..
EFREET .........
KNIGHT .........
NOTNOW .........
TEMPLE .........
VULCAN .........

Unless some version added a check in its code, you could simply type in a single word replacement for all 13 copy protection words.  Curse was trickier because it only required one letter or number, not a whole word.  Each type of line has six characters, making the range of options far greater.  There are five letter words prefaced by a number, but they are never called for.  You can find "GOOGLE" in the code wheel!

Commodore 64 and Apple II Versions of Pool of Radiance

Pool of Radiance was originally developed for the Commodore 64 and its capabilities but at some point during its development there was something of a shift to the IBM PC version.  The manual demonstrates this as it refers to options present in the IBM PC version but not in the C64 version.  

The C64 and Apple II versions came on four disks and used each side of the disk requiring flipping disk sides and swapping disks.  The IBM PC version came on three 5.25" disks but is compressed and cannot be run off the original disks.  It can be installed onto six 5.25" disks, four 3.5" disks, a mix of two 5.25" disks and three 3.5" disks or a hard drive with 1.75MiB free.  The IBM PC version requires two drives, the C64 and A2 versions only use one.

The C64 version does not require a disk swap until you pass the copy protection screen.  The Apple II version requires swapping disk sides in the following sequence to get to the title screen 1, 2, 3, 6 & 1. The Apple II loads disks faster but does not require any commands to start the boot, unlike the C64 version which requires two.  Between the disk booting commands of the C64 version and the extra disk swapping Apple II version the two games will take roughly one and a half minutes to reach the title screen.  

Of the Gold Box games, neither the C64 nor the Apple II allow you to complete any of the series, Pool, Krynn, Savage Frontier or Buck Rogers.  Only DOS allows you to complete them all, Amiga does not have the 2nd Buck Rogers game.  Macintosh and PC-98 only allow for completing the Pool series.  Both Amiga and Macintosh allow for hard drive installation.  The Amiga has the most colorful graphics sound of any English-language version of the game and digitized sound.  The Macintosh version supports either B&W Macs or Color Macs such as the Mac II, but the color graphics are identical to the IBM PC 16-color graphics.

Hard drives for the A2 and C64 did exist in their commercial lifespans but they were very expensive and were not compatible with Apple DOS 3.3 and CBM DOS, respectively.  Games for these 8-bit computers did not support hard drives but today we are more fortunate through the use of PRODOS and EasyFlash conversions.  They eliminate disk swapping and make game loading much, much faster.  

The IBM PCs and most compatibles had a numeric keypad on their keyboards, and the keypresses from the keypad can be easily distinguished by software from the keypresses on the number row of the main keyboard.  The Commodore 64 had no keypad, the backwards-compatible Commodore 128 did.  The Apple IIe and IIe Enhanced had an internal header to plug in a numeric keypad and the Apple IIe Platinum had one built-in.  The keys on these keypads when pressed are not distinguishable from their number row equivalents to software.  Neither the C64 nor the A2 support a keypad friendly cursor movement scheme.

This becomes an issue with combat.  In combat you can move in eight directions and can engage in a melee attack by moving to touch the opponent.  You can also manually select your target with a box, but this is more cumbersome.  In the IBM PC version the movement is centered on the keypad so the directions follow this clockwise pattern: 8 is Up, 9 is Up & Right, 6 is Right, 3 is Down & Right, 2 is Down, 1 is Down & Left, 4 is Left and 7 is Up & Left.  If you wish to use a diagonal you can press those buttons and the game will always go in the direction you want.

As the C64 and A2 versions do not support numeric keypads, they can either use a joystick or the number row for movement.  Using the joystick is not recommended for diagonal movement, the joystick is very imprecise and the game will usually read the stick as either one of the straight directionals.  Using number keys will give precise movement, but the arrangement is not as intuitive: 1 is Up, 2 is Up & Right, 3 is Right, 4 is Down & Right, 5 is Down, 6 is Down & Right, 7 is Right and 8 is Up & Left.  

Performing the wrong move in combat can have serious consequences, you may attack an enemy you do not wish, as you are assumed to wish to attack an enemy you move towards.  Even worse, if you move past a space where the enemy can attack, the enemy will gain a free attack from that move.

Interesting Features with Other Versions

The Amiga version has different title music from the PC and C64 versions and also plays a short theme when combat begins. It was the only Gold Box port which really used the 32-color mode of the Amiga to produce notably more colorful and detailed graphics.

The PC-88 and PC-98 versions use the same music compositions as was used in the NES and Famicom versions. This makes sense as all these versions were distributed by Pony Canyon. Even though both computer families support the same sound chips, they use different arrangements of the same underlying music. It should be noted that the PC-88 and PC-98 versions were released in 1989 while the Famicom and NES versions were released in 1991 and 1992, respectively. These versions do not come with a starting party or characters. They also have disk based copy protection in addition to the codewheel protection.

I downloaded "disk images" of the Macintosh version of Pool of Radiance from Macintosh Garden and I thought they were just something some random person slapped together because the installation, if you can call it that, is as janky as hell. Then I looked at the reference card of the Macintosh version from an eBay auction and found out that the install was done like that on purpose. Essentially the Macintosh install is like the PC compatible install in that the game stores its data as archive files on its disks. The PC has an installer which decompresses the archive files automatically onto hard disk or floppy disk but the Macintosh makes you decompress each archive, and there are six archive files, onto the destination disk using a program called UnStuffit.

No two platforms use exactly the same starting party. The Macintosh and C64 are very close, using the same names and classes, but there are a few differences. The PC-88 and PC-98  versions do not come with a starting party or characters, you have to create all of them. The PC, Macintosh and Amiga versions can be installed to a hard drive, other versions must be run off floppy disk.

NES Gameplay Trilogies

There are certain games, that while they are not part of an official series, in many respects could have been.  In these cases, the gameplay across the three games is similar.  In this blog entry I will identify groups of games which I believe share certain gameplay traits that make them an unofficial trilogy.

Gradius - Lifeforce - Jackal

All three of these games were developed by Konami and encompass what I call the Konami Shooter Trilogy.  Unlike Japan, the US did not receive a version of Gradius 2 or Parodius, but Europe never saw Jackal either.  I note that Stinger was also released by Konami, but while it is a fine game in its own right I do not consider it to be in the same league in terms of popularity or adolescent-focused pure shooting action as these games.

All three of these games began life as arcade machines.  Gradius received a very faithful Arcade-to-NES port, although it lacks a bit in the flash and polish department. Jackal is also arcade-faithful as well, but Konami truly excelled here at bringing the fast-paced destruction of this game to the less capable hardware of the NES.  Nothing essential is lost in porting.  In fact, the game is substantially  improved by end-level bosses and level transitions.  As I mentioned elsewhere, Life Force is in certain respects a better game than its arcade original, Salamander.

Of course, I cannot go without mentioning the two player simultaneous gameplay of Jackal and Life Force. Two-player simultaneous gameplay was somewhat uncommon in the days of the NES due to the hardware limitations.  64 sprites get used up very quickly, and the 8 sprites per line limitation of the NES leads to flickering very quickly.  Konami was one of the few developers who consistently could do it right with Jackal, Life Force, Contra and Super C.

Zanac - The Guardian Legend - Gun+Nac

Here we have the Compile Shooter Trilogy.  Zanac and GunNac (note the similarity of the names) are similar in that their basic gameplay model is that of the vertical shooter.  The Guardian Legend combines vertical shooting stages with exploration-style bird's eye view stages like The Legend of Zelda.

Zanac has three principal strengths.  First, it has a wide variety of powerups (eight) that have their own strengths and weaknesses.  Second, it has very solid gameplay, especially for a somewhat early title.  It is a fairly fast paced game, the controls are very responsive, rapid fire is present.  Even though it lacks varied bosses, it feels very modern.  The graphics are good and the music is excellent.  Third, the game adapts itself to the power ups you choose and reportedly your skill level.  It is not simply a randomizer, the game will behave in somewhat predictable ways, in terms of the enemies it will throw at you, based on the active weapon powerup you possess.  This mechanic makes it never quite the same game twice. You can continue at the last area by pressing start and select at the same time on the title screen (this is in the manual).

The Guardian Legend tweaks the formula quite a bit by adding overhead exploration.  You collect chips to buy items from the Blue Landers, fight bosses in special rooms and collect keys to open "corridors" to vertical shooting stages.  Your character is not just a ship but a female android (which the US version took some pains to obfuscate).  It has a password feature for restoring your game, and it is pretty long by NES standards.  There are several themes to individual areas, like water, plants and mountains, and the graphics change accordingly.  The music is some of the best on the NES.  Shooting stage bosses are varied and some are really tough (blue Optomon will make you throw your controller against the TV screen) and others are much more reasonable (even the red Clawbot and Bombarder are reasonable).  Finally, you gain many weapons and you can switch between them as often as you like, but you use up chips by using them.  Fortunately, the game is fairly generous with supplying you with chips and health items when you need them.  By inputting the password TGL, you can play the game as a straight shooter.

Gun+Nac is as to Zanac as Parodius is as to Gradius.  Unfortunately, Gun+Nac is not as well-known as it deserves to be because it was released rather late in the NES's lifespan.  Gun+Nac plays like Zanac with more powerups.  You still collect the Compile "P" chips, but you also collect money so you can upgrade your ship and buy extra lives during the levels.  GunNac is cute and goofy with rabbit and cat enemies, but do not let that fool you into thinking the game is a cakewalk, it is not.  Graphics and sound are excellent.

Golgo 13: Top Secret Episode - The Mafat Conspiracy -  WURM: Journey to the Center of the Earth

Golgo 13 and its sequel the Mafat Conspiracy are a logical choices because they use the Golgo-13 character, but WURM?  It is not as far fetched as you think.  Golgo 13 advertised multiple styles of play.  First, there are side-scrolling areas with some platform (enemy bases) and some free form (underwater) elements like Super Mario Bros.  Second, there are first person, 360 degree mode instances where you have to kill all the enemies that are ambushing you. Third, there are horizontal shooter stages when you fly a helicopter. Fourth, there are first person maze stages with traps, items and enemies to shoot.  Finally, there are dialogue and cinematic sequences when you charm the ladies.

The Mafat Conspiracy has more of the same, mostly.  In exchange for the horizontal shooting mode, you get a driving mode that looks very close to Rad Racer.  There is also a more involved sniping mode and the game is much more cinematic overall.  The mazes are still as annoying as hell, but in the manuals for both games there are maps.  Also, the platforming stages are still a bit stiff in terms of your character's control scheme but there have been some improvements from the first game.  One big one is that now button B shoots and button A jumps, it was swapped for Golgo 13.

WURM shares the jack-of-all-trades gameplay style of the Golgo-13 games.  It starts you out with a horizontal shooter stage.  You will see more than one of these and your vehicle has and can acquire several different abilities and powerups.   Second, you will have a 360 degree first person mode where you fight boss monsters.  Third, you will explore various areas as Moby in side-scrolling stages.  Moby has a gun and can kick and she controls very similarly to Golgo-13.  Like Golgo-13, the enemies on these stages are not known for their variety.  Fourth comes vertical shooter stages, which are a bit more rudimentary than the horizontal stages.  Fifth, there are also cinematic cutscenes, but these suffer from a lot of repetition in terms of dialogue and artwork.  You also have dialogue during boss fights.  Similarly to Golgo-13, you can also engage in dialogue during the side-scrolling stages.

Golgo 13 and WURM share the same designer, Shoichi Yoshikawa, and he acknowledges that he took inspiration from the earlier game.  He even made a direct reference by including the "G-13" robot in the game.   However, WURM has an unfinished feel to it that cannot be said for the Golgo-13 games.

Arkanoid and Arkanoid Again

Arkanoid, that timeless classic from Taito, breathed new life into the Breakout-style of gameplay.  It was ported to the IBM PC compatible platform by Novalogic for Taito in 1988.  What I did not know was that this Novalogic port was based off an earlier port by Imagine.

Imagine was a British software developer in the mid 1980s that went bankrupt.  Ocean Software bought the name and used it on a label for several arcade game ports.  This port of Arkanoid is the only PC port I am aware of which used the Imagine label.  This port was released in 1987.  This PC port was ported from the more colorful ZX Spectrum version, which may be why the Imagine label was left on it.  It only supports CGA graphics and keyboard controls.

Taito had Novalogic port the game again with the mandate to include better hardware support.  Novalogic did not start from scratch, as you will see.  They upgraded the graphics to 16-color EGA and Tandy support,  which required redoing the CGA graphics.  They also included mouse and joystick support and Tandy 3-voice support for music.  Sound effects were still PC Speaker based.

If you compare screenshots of the Imagine and Taito versions, you will see many, many similarities.  Let's start with the Imagine version of Arkanoid :

Now let us compare the CGA graphics of Taito's version :

And here are the customary 16-color graphics for reference :

Both disks are copy protected, but in very different ways.  Taito's executable protected with the Softguard protection.  The executable is encrypted and the loader program makes multiple checks for errors on a track of the disk, then if it is sufficiently satisfied that the errors exist, it will decrypt and run the real executable. Imagine's disk appears as a 180KB single sided disk but is really a double sided disk.  The executable is located on the second side of the disk.  DOS cannot see or execute the executable, but the game's loader reads the data directly through Int 13h read sector commands.  

The Imagine port uses tweaked PC speaker music to get more than one voice out of the PC speaker.  The Taito port uses simple PC speaker music.  The Taito 3-voice music is not particularly more complex or impressive compared to the PC speaker music.  However, unlike the Imagine port, the Taito port is not quite as speed sensitive.  It is almost certain that the Imagine port was developed on or for an Amstrad PC-1512, which uses an 8MHz 8086 and a built-in enhanced CGA graphics adapter.  Both versions quit the game by pressing Esc, then Q, which is weird for PC games but not so much for the small keyboard of the ZX Spectrum.

While neither port will win any prizes for "Best Port of Arkanoid", Taito's version is the better version.  Although it only gives you 3 lives to Imagine's 5, the control responsiveness from the mouse, the joystick or even the keyboard of the Taito version is far superior to the keyboard controls of the Imagine version.  The Imagine's paddle will frequently jerk to the left or the right when you change direction instead of giving a proper smooth movement.  The hit detection between the ball and paddle is more consistent in the Taito version.  Finally, the Imagine version does not seem to have the enemies appear from the top of the screen.  I could not see them in the first two rounds.  Note that the best joystick for the Taito version is one where you can turn the self-centering off, as you can on the boxy Kraft or Tandy Deluxe joysticks.

The real Arkanoid in the arcades used a "spinner", which is a rotary dial.  A rotary dial works by phase shifted quadrature encoding.  There are a pair of optical sensors on either side of a wheel with spokes and holes.  There is an invisible beam between the optical sensors, which are positioned off center from each other.  When the wheel is turned one way, the optical sensor sends a signal.  When it is turned the other way, it sends a mirror image of that signal.  The signal is made up of 1s and 0s sent in a waveform out of phase with each other, and the signal that goes from low to high or high to low first determines the direction.  

The rotary encoder used by Arkanoid was a huge improvement over the resistor capacitor design of older paddle control knobs.  The resistor/capacitor scheme was never especially accurate because it relied on the tolerances of the passive components which could very widely.  Moveover, a potentiometer in a paddle does not have a 360 degree range of movement.  A rotary encoder put out a pure digital signal, the only analog element of the design was how fast the player twisted the knob.  

Your standard ball mouse uses two rotary controllers.  It is by far the closest control to an arcade Arkanoid cabinet as you can get on the PC without buying a MAME controller.  Most MAME controllers are USB based these days, and classic computers tend to be rather incompatible with USB controllers.  

I thought of adapting an Atari 2600 driving controller to a PC mouse interface, because it is essentially half of a mouse.  However, the driving controller puts out a pure quadrature signal.  Serial mice collect the quadrature signals from the movement and the button presses with a microcontroller built into the mouse and send them out in byte-packets to the serial port.  A bus mouse interface like the Microsoft InPort interface may be possible because it accepts quadrature signals from the mouse and has the microcontroller on a PC card.  But an Atari 2600 driving controller only has 16 positions in a complete revolution while your average comptuer mouse has double the number of positions.  The 2600 controller would not be sufficiently fine tuned for games that expect a mouse like Arkanoid and Arkanoid 2: Revenge of DOH, or Cyberball Plus.  

The Imagine version of Arkanoid that has been given to me to write about came on a compilation package called  "La Collection Amstrad PC."  This Collection contains four titles distributed by U.S. Gold: World Class Leader Board from Access Software, World Games from Epyx, Arkanoid (originally from Taito) and "Super Tennis".  "Super Tennis" shares the disk with Arkanoid and boots to this menu :

I know World Class Leader Board and World Games well enough because they came from U.S. companies, but I was not immediately familiar with "Super Tennis".  "Super Tennis" uses French in game and only supports CGA and PC Speaker.  Fortunately its limited hardware selection made it easy enough to track its source, which is Tournament Tennis, originally from Imagic and originally in English. Tournament Tennis has some support for CGA composite color graphics, which would have been unheard of for a European developed title, which cannot support CGA composite graphics because of the lack of NTSC monitors.  Like Arkanoid, Super Tennis appears to be speed adjusted for an 8MHz 8086 machine.  

Here are some screenshots games from Super Tennis :

And here are screenshots from Tournament Tennis as translated into French :

Atari Hardware Explained

The Atari 2600 is a very compact system, even though this may not be reflected in the standard woodgrain case in which it is housed.  Inside each system are three chips, the CPU, the Television Interface Adapter (TIA) and the RAM, Input, Output & Timer (RIOT).  These three chips work together along with a cartridge, switches and a controller to display games to a TV.  Lets discuss how the design of these chips influences the games that were produced.

CPU

First, lets start with the CPU, which is a MOS 6507 (a.k.a. C010745).  The 6507 is a budget version of the 6502 an in the Atari 2600 it runs at 1.19MHz (1/3 of the NTSC color clock frequency).  It is a fully-functional 6502 in a 28-pin package.  The full 6502 comes in a 40-pin package.  As a result of the size reduction there is no support for hardware interrupts and the 6507 only has 13 (of a maximum of 16) address lines.  This limits the amount of addressable memory that the CPU can access directly to 8KB (kilobytes).  Unlike the NES's 6502 variant, the 6507 has a functional binary-coded decimal mode.  The TIA is connected to the CPU's RDY line, so it can halt the processor.

RIOT

Next comes the RIOT chip, which is an MOS 6532 Peripheral Interface Adapter (a.k.a. C010750).  This 40-pin chip contains a programmable timer, 128 bytes of RAM and two 8-bit parallel input and output ports.  It has 9 registers, some of which are read only, some write and some can do both.  The timer counts down an 8-bit value by one of four orders of magnitude.  128 bytes of RAM substantially limits the complexity of games because that is where all a program's variables must live.  In addition, this RAM is also used by the stack.  The stack is vital for subroutines, which can be many in a game.  On the plus side, the RAM is located in the 6507's zero page, so accessing it will be fast.

One of the I/O ports is exclusively used for input from the five switches on the console, one bit for each switch.  Each bit of the second I/O port can be set to be an input or an output.  As an input, it reads the four directions from each joystick (one direction per bit), the paddle button from each of the four paddles or the position of the driving controller.  As an output, it strobes the keyboard controllers.  This I/O port can also be used to write to and read from more modern port peripherals like the AtariVox.

TIA - Input and Sound

Finally we come to the TIA, the most complex chip in the system.  This is a custom 40-pin Atari chip C010444D which Atari strangely never got around to patenting, leading to cloned chips from Mattel and Coleco later in the 2600's life.  It was never an off-the-shelf chip, unlike the 6507 and 6532.  The TIA handles all graphics and interfacing with the TV, all sound and handles the remainder of the inputs.  It is also mapped into the zero page of the 2600's memory map.  It contains 45 write-only registers and 14 read-only registers.  Let's discuss its features in inverse order of complexity.

The TIA has four input ports, each dedicated to the input from a single paddle.  Paddles are read in a way similar to how a joystick is on the IBM PC.  A write to a certain register discharges the a capacitor and the position of a connected potentiomer dictates how long it takes to charge the capacitor.  The length of time it takes the capacitor to charge dictates the position of the paddle.  These registers also are used to read the keyboard controllers.  Essentially the keyboard controllers act like paddles set to a specified resistance value.  It also has two ports for reading the state of the joystick switches or the driving controller buttons.

Sound on the 2600 is geared more toward creating interesting sound effect than music.  Each of the two audio channels can emit a pure square wave tone, but there are only five bits to divide the frequency. The range of the 2600 is from 30,000Hz (divide by 1) to 937.5Hz (divide by 32).  Even the less than impressive TI SN 76489/96 has 11-bits of frequency control.  There are 4-bits of volume control, but the 2600 is just not very musical.  Even so, some games like Gyruss, Mountain King and Supercharger Frogger have impressive music.  The noise is based off a polynomial counter tweaked by various settings. There are 16 combinations (10 unique) of tone and noise to choose from in the 2600, and they are much more geared to sound effects.  You can hear what each selection and frequency sounds like here : http://www.randomterrain.com/atari-2600-memories-batari-basic-music-toy.html

TIA - Graphics

Most of the CPU's time is spent drawing the graphics, line by line.  The 2600 does not have a frame buffer and it does not have dedicated video memory.  More modern game consoles write the graphics data into a frame buffer and into sprite memory and let the video display chip take care of drawing it to the screen.

Atari 2600 graphics have to be fed into the TIA each and every line that the TV draws.  Whatever time is left over during horizontal blanking (the time it takes for the TV's electron beam to return from the right side of the screen to the left) is spent on setting up the graphics for the next line.  This is what is called racing the beam.  The vertical blanking period, (the time it takes for the beam to return to the top left portion of the screen from the bottom right) is typically used for game logic, sound and input reading.

The Atari 2600 is capable of displaying 128 colors, 8 of which are solely grayscale from black to white.  The remainder are spread across the NTSC color wheel with a great variety of variation.  The horizontal resolution of the Atari 2600 is always 160 pixels.  The vertical resolution of the Atari 2600 is not fixed but typically is 192 lines.  It is up to the programmer to start the vertical retrace period.

The graphics are made up of seven elements, a background color, a playfield, two players, two missiles and a ball object.  The background and the playfield make up what would be known in later consoles as the background graphics and the player, missile and ball objects would later be known as the sprite graphics.

Combat - Note the reflected playfield and the two players.  Each player fires a missle with the same color

The background color a single color that is set for the entire TV area, unless changed on a particular scanline.  When the color is changed it can be masked by the playfield.  Air-Sea Battle has frequent changes of the background color.

The playfield consists of 20 bits per line.  If a bit is on, the playfield color is displayed.  If the color is off, then the background color is displayed.  Each bit of the playfield is four pixels wide, giving the backgrounds to Atari 2600 games a characteristic low resolution look.  Additionally, those 20-bits only cover the left side of the screen, so the right side of the screen displays a duplicate or a mirror image of the left side of the screen.  This tends to give the backgrounds a symmetrical look in many Atari 2600 games.

Combat - Note the second copy of Player 2, the repeated playfield and that the playfield has priority over the players

When you see counters or scores on the top of the screen, these are usually playfield graphics.  But as I mentioned, there is only enough room in the playfield registers for half the screen, so what happens when one side's 0 turns into a 1?  You can time your writes to the playfield registers in mid scanline so you get a different playfield on the right side as opposed to the left side.  You can also set the colors of each side to the colors of the player 1 and player 2 objects.

Video Olympics - The ball object is used, and the scores are playfield bits changed in midscanline

The ball object is a one pixel object that can be placed anywhere on a scanline.  It uses the same color as the playfield on the same scanline.  The ball was intended to make Pong games like Video Olympics possible on the 2600.

The player objects are up to eight pixels wide, with a 1 bit showing the player color and a 0 bit showing a background or playfield color.  Two players, two colors.  Each player has a one pixel missile object associated with it which is the same color as the player.  Each player and missle object can also be placed anywhere on a scanline.  Multi-colored objects are accomplished by changing the color of the player object each line.  These graphics are best suited for Tank-line games like Combat.

Space Invaders - The player cannon is stretched, and each invader is a player copied twice, the copy is removed when shot

Ball and missile objects can be stretched to 2, 4 or 8 pixels.  Each player object can have one or two additional copies spaced at set intervals.  This is what makes Space Invaders possible.  The player can be stretched 2x or 3x horizontally and be reflected (to face left instead of right).  Players and missiles are typically displayed over the playfield graphics, but can be set to have the playfield graphics displayed over them.

In many games like Space Invaders and Ms. Pac Man, you will see a serrated series of lines across the left border of the screen.  These lines are used to delay the start of the graphics drawing, giving the programmer more time to write graphics to the next line.  In the 2600, you always have to be one line ahead of the raster. In fact, the standard Activision practice was to blank out the entire left column of the screen for 8 pixels or so.

Pitfall - Player, missile, ball and playfield graphics all combine on various scanlines to make a complex background

In Video Checkers, there are four pieces per row, three of which are provided by a player object and one provided by a stretched missile object.  Lucky for Atari standard checkers is played with a maximum of four pieces per row.  However, the same effect is insufficient for Chess.  Atari used a Venetian Blinds effect used in Video Chess.  This is necessary because each player object can only draw three objects on a line, and you need eight in chess.  So in Video Chess, they alternated the drawing of the chess pieces every other line. This eliminated flickering.  They also had to alter the player graphics in mid-frame in order to make the king's row pieces distinct for each side.

Yar's Revenge - The Neutral Zone is a visual representation of the game's code

Color cycling was one of the hallmarks of Atari graphics, from the Chalice in Adventure to the Neutral Zone in Yar's Revenge.  The color registers are often updated many times per second.  In Yar's Revenge, the bit pattern of the code in ROM was used to give a pseudo-random appearance to the Neutral Zone.  Color cycling was also done for many of the early 2600 games because this was believed to reduce screen burn-in if the TV and the 2600 were left on.

Video Checkers - Each Player has two copies and stretched missiles make up the fourth checker on each row

Scrolling the screen was uncommon on the 2600 because there were no scrolling registers, everything had to be done in software.  Vertical scrolling was easier due to the line-based nature of Atari graphics and because the programmer could tell the TIA when to stop drawing scanlines.  Raiders of the Lost Ark, Jr. Pac-Man and Haunted House all have vertical scrolling.  Horizontal scrolling was a bit trickier, but it could be done.  Mountain King, Stargate/Defender II and Dragonstomper all do it well.

Video Checkers - Each piece is a Player object is staggered compared to the next and drawn every other line.  The background is very large to give the programmer more time to update the individual pixel patterns without flickering

There are hardware collision registers for each combination between the six objects.  Reading a register will tell you if there was an intersection between player 1 and missile 2, for example.  While this saves the programmer from having to determine the collision by having to compare the position values of the two characters, it can also lead to too-strict hit control.  If a missile hit a non-visible player pixel, it will still register a hit.

The Stella emulator can turn on and off each of the objects at will.  If you ever wonder how so few objects can make up the screen, try turning off some.  Collisions can be disabled as well, people tend to use this to cheat.

Cartridges and Memory

Standard Atari 2600 Cartridges contain a 2KB or 4KB ROM chip.  4KB is the maximum amount of ROM the 2600 can address without any bankswitching hardware.  To address more ROM, you had to include additional hardware in the cartridge to handle the swapping.  Most bankswitching schemes reserve certain addresses.  When you write a value to the reserved address, it swaps in another 4KB section of the ROM. Some schemes are more complicated, but this is the general idea.

Asteroids was the first commercially released game to use more than 4KB.  Approximately 20% of Atari 2600 games used more than 4KB of ROM, and almost none used more than 16KB.  However, most Atari 2600 games did not have title screens because they always require precious space in ROM to program.  The title on the cartridge should have been enough for everybody, or so the thinking went.  Also, if you wanted to know what the differences between the various game options are, you have to look in the manual or figure it out through observation.  There was no space for the game itself to explain options.

Some Atari 2600 Cartridges also include additional RAM, usually 128 or 256 bytes.  This RAM is mapped somewhere into the cartridge space and one set of 128 or 256 byte addresses is used for reading and a second set is used for writing.  This is because there is no read/write line sent to the cartridge slot.

The most unique game device for the 2600 was the Starpath Supercharger, which transferred binary data played on cassette tapes to a large cartridge which contained 6KB of RAM and a ADC.  I have discussed this device's operation in more detail elsewhere : http://nerdlypleasures.blogspot.com/2014/06/arcadiastarpath-supercharger-cassette.html

The B&W switch on the 2600 does nothing if the program ignores it.  If the program responds to the B&W switch as it was meant to be used, it will set the graphics to use colors that will show up better on a B&W TV.  B&W TVs only understand the eight levels of luminance the Atari 2600 provides.  However, there is nothing special about the B&W switch or any of the other non-power switches, and the B&W switch was used for other purposes on occasion : http://nerdlypleasures.blogspot.com/2015/03/the-forgotten-switch-atari-2600s-b.html

Enhancements

The TIA contains two audio channels that operate identically but are mixed together outside the chip.  The 2600 was originally planned to be a stereo console with two speakers installed in the 2600's case, but this idea was scrapped as being too costly.  Some of the earliest games (Combat) and a few homebrews (Medieval Mayhem) support stereo audio, but you have to modify your system to hear stereo audio.

The Atari 2600 outputs RF video only, which is less than desirable in the year 2015 for many people.  The chip outputs the color, c-sync and three luminance levels on separate lines.  The luminance levels are mixed and balanced with an R2R network and mixed with the other signals and sent to the RF modulator.  Composite and S-Video mods have existed for years.  However, S-Video is the best you can get from the TIA without substantial additional hardware.

There is an Atari 2600RGB adapter which will provide RGB video. It requires removing the TIA chip and inserting it into a custom board.  The board has an FPGA that will take the values in the color registers and translate them into RGB values.  It will also provide S-Video and Composite Video output.  Because there are only six graphical objects and the background color and four color palettes to keep track of, the FPGA can keep track of this by snooping on writes to these color palette registers.  In order to keep track of the objects as the pixels are displayed, each set of objects is assigned a different black and white palette and intercepts all writes to the palette registers.

Because of the non-standardized method (every game can do it differently) the 2600 uses to indicate that it is time to do vertical blank to the TV, some games may have some trouble when upscaled with an X-RGB Mini Framemeister. The original Warlords is one such game and there is a patch available.